My near philosophical musings about the world in general its problems and possible ways out.

2025-01-02

Software: Restructuring a troubled project in public transport

The Quality Tigers at work

Dr. Horst Walther

Industry: Information Technology (Software for Public Transport)

Line function: IT (Head of Professional Services)

Topic: Restructuring, Turnaround, Kanban, Scrum

Revenue: €10 million

Employees: 120

The Task

A key manager responsible for a software company's flagship product had resigned. This move came unexpectedly, as the highly anticipated new version of the flagship software was about to be released.

There had been no shortage of subtle warning signs. Several internal and external indicators pointed to risks in the technology, functionality, and market readiness of this next-generation product, eagerly awaited by the customer base. Top management apparently hadn't paid the necessary attention to these warning signals.

Immediate action was now required to ensure the release could still proceed as planned. On the other hand, filling the vacant position in a highly transparent market was a prudent move that had to be carried out with the necessary care and caution, and without undue haste.

An experienced interim manager was needed who could quickly take the reins and keep the business running smoothly. While work continued as planned, he was to find, select, and train his successor.

Solution

A three-stage approach had already been agreed upon in advance:

  1. Diagnosis – Over a period of six weeks, the future interim manager took on an observer role, participated in all key events, conducted interviews, and studied technical documents.

  2. Immediate Measures – Following an approach that can be aptly abbreviated as CCC (Cash, Cost & Customers), the necessary budget had to be secured, identifiable cost-saving potential had to be utilized, and renewed confidence had to be conveyed to the uncertain customer base. The focus then shifted inward, to the root causes that had ultimately led to this difficult situation.

  3. Revitalization - Agilization, Metric, Quality Management,

Diagnosis

To narrow down the problem area, identify and assess existing vulnerabilities, and ultimately estimate the scope of necessary measures, the following analytical steps were initiated:

  • Estimation of the system size, expressed in lines of code (LoC) and function points (fp) of SAP ABAP code by applying a Backfiring methodology.
  • Architecture and design validation using a selected third-party measurement tool.
  • Application of a standard defect model, especially to determine the expected number of undiscovered defects.
  • Management, reclassification, and prioritization of defects in a defect database based on customer feedback plus expert assessment.

It quickly became clear that, despite the best intentions of launching a particularly high-performing product, a code monster burdened with a great deal of technical debt had been created. Its maintainability limitations were now becoming apparent. At the same time, the next version was due for release. In the meantime, existing customers waited impatiently for a long list of known bugs to be fixed.

The feeling among the employees that they had lost control of the process was confirmed by the quantitative findings. In their distress, they resorted to mutual blame. The working atmosphere suffered considerably as a result.

It had thus become clear that the interim management phase would not simply be a temporary solution to a personnel vacancy. The interim manager therefore had to deliver a convincing turnaround strategy. He also had to possess the charisma to bring the team and management on board for what was expected to be a difficult journey.

Immediate measures

And this is where we started, with the development teams. In an all-hands meeting, the critical situation was officially presented to the staff for the first time. After initial strong emotions, it eventually became clear to everyone involved that the goal of an effective turnaround could only be achieved together.

The stated guiding principle of "quality before deadline" was ultimately received with relief, and the release of the new version was halted until sufficient system stability was achieved.

Since a lack of or dysfunctional inter-team communication had been identified as a major obstacle, all developers now gathered daily at the start of their workday in front of the Kanban board to coordinate testing and bug fixing.

Comprehensive communication was also the key factor in winning over impatient customers to the new "no more false promises" strategy. —and in return, to obtain their approval for the one-time extended delivery deadline.

The product under development was functionally quite attractive, promised to fulfil many long-held wishes of the transport companies, and, thanks to its document-oriented workflow concept, was a favourite of the external auditors. The understanding shown to us, albeit reluctantly, was only a step in the right direction, a trust that we first had to earn back.

Even though the “customer is king,” the next step was to be completely honest with the shareholders represented on the advisory board and win them over to the new approach. They ultimately accept the emergency action plan – also due to a lack of realistic alternatives.

The full focus on the "Quality First Paradigm" in all phases of software development, supplemented by an emphasis on a "Clean Code" approach and random checks of its compliance by newly appointed "Quality Tigers," and the practical implementation of this approach.

Agile management methods – Scrum for implementation projects, Kanban for maintenance activities – rounded off the necessary immediate measures.

Revitalization

Even though the sprint for the upcoming delivery of the "next-generation software" yielded initial successes, it had become clear that we were not yet adequately prepared for the marathon ahead. The changing market, with its new and dynamic competitors, new requirements, and increased price sensitivity among customer groups, demanded increased productivity and, at the same time, greater cost efficiency.

Given the increased demands on the one hand and the distressingly high level of technical debt on the other, the medium-term measure of exploring the possibility of outsourcing particularly resource-intensive tasks to a lower-cost country via "nearshoring" was undertaken.

In order to outsource these tasks, system documentation and training materials first had to be updated and translated into English. The nearshoring teams under consideration were often far ahead of us in the application of agile development methods. A training program for internal staff therefore had to be set up immediately.

The complex transformation of the entire development department, the heart of the company, had to be justified by ambitious growth targets in a market that was fortunately not yet saturated.

This meant, among other things, supporting various national architectural standards for public transport. Internally, product and project business had to be separated and professionalized.

The ruthlessly realistic investment forecast, presented as an essential part of a long-term business plan, initially raised eyebrows among the shareholders but was ultimately accepted.

Part of this included a proposed new management structure for the "Professional Services" division, the hiring of a product manager and a service delivery manager, and finally, the handover to the new management.

Result

On the one hand, the New transparency helped to open the eyes of management and the board of directors to the seriousness of the situation and the extent of the "technical debt" accumulated over the years.

On the other hand, the revitalization program developed a strong persuasive power. The presented vision was supported by solid numerical calculations. While the presented business plan showed high investments to pay off the technical debt accumulated over the past years, it promised a positive cash flow after approximately two years.

Meanwhile, the ad-hoc activities showed initial positive results and strengthened confidence in the feasibility of this project. With renewed hope and the first positive signals from the market, the handover to the new management gave the company new momentum and was generally perceived as a new beginning.

Dr. Horst Walther

SiG Software Integration GmbH
Große Bleichen 1-3
20354 Hamburg

horst.walther@si-g.com
https//www.si-g.com

+49 171 214 55 02

Software: Restrukturierung eines Desaster-Projekts im ÖPNV

Branche: Informationstechnologie (Software für den öffentlicher Personenverkehr)

Linienfunktion: IT (Leiter Professional Services)

Thema: Restrukturierung, Turnaround, Kanban, Scrum

Umsatz: 10 Mio. Euro

Mitarbeiter: 120

Aufgabe:

Ein wichtiger Manager, der für das Hauptprodukt eines Softwarehauses verantwortlich war, hatte sein Arbeitsverhältnis gekündigt. Dieser Schritt kam unerwartet, dabei stand die mit hohen Erwartungen verbundene neue Version der Flaggschiff-Software kurz vor der Auslieferung.

An subtilen Vorwarnungen hatte es nicht gefehlt. Mehrere interne und externe Indikatoren deuteten auf Risiken bei Technologie, Funktionalität und Marktreife dieses von der Kundenbasis sehnlichst erwarteten Produkts der nächsten Generation hin. Den Warnsignalen war von Seiten des Top-Managements offenbar nicht die erforderliche Aufmerksamkeit geschenkt worden.

Jetzt bestand dringender Handlungsbedarf, damit die Auslieferung noch plangemäß durchgeführt werden konnte. Andererseits war die Besetzung der vakanten Position in einem kleinen und hochtransparenten Markt ein sensibler Akt, der mit der notwendigen Sorgfalt, Vorsicht und ohne erkennbare Eile durchgeführt werden musste.

Dafür wurde ein erfahrener Interim Manager benötigt, der schnell die Zügel in die Hand nehmen und das Geschäft weiterführen konnte. Während die Arbeiten nach Plan weitergeführt würden, sollte er seinen Nachfolger finden, auswählen und einarbeiten.

Lösung

Bereits im Vorfeld war eine dreistufige Herangehensweise vereinbart worden:
  1. Diagnose – Über einen Zeitraum von 6 Wochen nahm der spätere Interim Manager eine Beobachterrolle ein, nahm an allen wesentlichen Veranstaltungen teil, führte Interviews und studierte einschlägige Unterlagen.

  2. Sofortmaßnahmen – Nach einem Ansatz, der sich eingängig als CCC (Cash, Cost & Customers) abkürzt, musste zunächst das erforderliche Budget gesichert, erkennbares Kostensenkungspotential genutzt und der verunsicherten Kundenbasis neue Zuversicht vermittelt werden. Anschließend wurde der Blick nach innen, auf die eigentlichen Ursachen gerichtet, die schließlich zu dieser schwierigen Situation geführt hatten.

  3. Revitalisierung – Agilisierung, Metrik, Qualitätsmanagement, Organisationskultur und Resilienz waren die Überschriften zu den mittel- bis langfristigen Maßnahmen, die die folgenden zwei Jahre prägen sollten.

Diagnose

Um den Problembereich einzugrenzen, bestehende Schwachstellen zu identifizieren und zu bewerten und schließlich das Ausmaß der zu treffenden Maßnahmen abschätzen zu können, wurden folgende analytische Schritte eingeleitet:

  • Architektur- und Entwurfsvalidierung mit einem ausgewählten Messwerkzeug eines Drittanbieters.
  • Anwendung eines Standardfehlermodells, insbesondere zur Ermittlung der zu erwartende Menge noch unentdeckter Fehler.
  • Verwaltung, Neuklassifizierung und Priorisierung der Mängel in einer Mängeldatenbank nach Kundenfeedback plus Expertenurteil.

Schnell wurde klar, dass in der besten Absicht, ein funktional besonders leistungsfähiges Produkt auf den Markt zu bringen, ein mit vielen technischen Schulden beladenes Codemonster geschaffen worden war. Dessen Grenzen der Wartbarkeit wurden jetzt deutlich. Gleichzeitig aber stand die nächste Version zur Auslieferung an. In der Zwischenzeit warteten bestehende Kunden ungeduldig darauf, dass eine längere Liste bekannter Fehler behoben würde.

Das unter den Mitarbeitern bereits latent vorhandene Gefühl, das Verfahren nicht mehr im Griff zu haben, wurde durch die quantitativen Feststellungen für alle zur Gewissheit. In ihrer Not griffen sie zu wechselseitigen Schuldzuweisungen. Das Betriebsklima litt erheblich darunter.

Dass die Phase des Interim Managements keine reine Überbrückung einer personellen Vakanz würde, war damit klar geworden. Der Interim Manager musste mithin eine überzeugende Turnaround-Strategie liefern. Auch musste er über das Charisma verfügen, Team und Management für eine erwartungsgemäß unbequeme Reise an Bord zu holen.

Sofortmaßnahmen:

Und hier, bei den Entwicklerteams, setzten wir auch den Ansatzpunkt. In einem All-hands-Meeting wurde der Belegschaft die kritische Situation zu ersten Mal offiziell präsentiert. Nachdem die Emotionen zunächst hohe Wellen schlugen, war am Ende allen Beteiligten klargeworden, dass das Ziel eines wirksamen Turnarounds nur gemeinsam zu erreichen war.

Das ausgegebene Grundprinzip „Qualität vor Termin" wurde letztlich mit Erleichterung aufgenommen, die Auslieferung der neuen Version gestoppt, bis eine ausreichende Systemstabilität erreicht würde.

Da fehlende oder dysfunktionale inter-Team Kommunikation als wesentliches Hemmnis erkannt worden war, versammelten sich ab sofort alle Entwickler täglich zu Arbeitsbeginn vor dem Kanban-Bord, um Test und Fehlerbehebung zu koordinieren.

Umfassende Kommunikation war auch der Schlüsselfaktor, um die ungeduldigen Kunden für die neue Strategie "keine falschen Versprechungen mehr" zu gewinnen – und im Gegenzug ihre Zustimmung für die einmalig verlängerte Lieferfrist zu erhalten.

Das in der Entwicklung befindliche Produkt war funktional durchaus attraktiv, versprach viele von den Verkehrsunternehmen langgehegte Wünsche zu erfüllen und war durch sein belegorientiertes Ablaufkonzept der Liebling der externen Auditoren. Das uns notgedrungen entgegengebrachte Verständnis war aber nur ein Vorschuss auf ein Vertrauen, dass wir uns erst wieder erarbeiten mussten.

Auch, wenn der „Kunde König" ist, galt es als nächstes, den im Beitrat vertretenen Gesellschaftern „reinen Wein" einzuschenken, und sie für das neue Vorgehen zu gewinnen. Sie akzeptieren den Notfallaktionsplan schließlich – auch mangels realistischer Alternativen.

Die volle Konzentration auf das "Quality First Paradigma" in allen Phasen der Software-Entwicklung, ergänzt um die Betonung eines "Clean Code"-Ansatzes und der stichprobenartigen Prüfung seiner Einhaltung durch neu ernannte „Quality-Tigers" und die praktische Einführung agiler Managementmethoden – Scrum für Implementierungsprojekte, Kanban für Wartungsaktivitäten – rundeten die erforderlichen Sofortmaßnamen ab.

Revitalisierung

Auch wenn der Sprint zur anstehenden Auslieferung der „Next-Generation Software" erste Erfolge zeitigte, war doch deutlich geworden, dass wir für den vor uns liegenden Marathon noch nicht ausreichend aufgestellt waren. Der sich wandelnde Markt mit neuen vitalen Wettbewerbern, neuen Anforderungen und einer höheren Preissensitivität der Kundengruppen verlangte nach Steigerung der Produktivität und gleichzeitig höherer Kosteneffizienz.

Angesichts der gestiegenen Anforderungen einerseits und dem bedrückend hohen Bestand an technischen Schulden wurde als mittelfristige Maßnahme die Prüfung der Auslagerung von besonders aufwändigen Tätigkeiten per „Nearshoring" in ein Land mit niedrigeren Kosten angegangen.

Um Tätigkeiten vergeben zu können mussten System-Dokumentation und Schulungsmaterial zunächst auf einen aktuellen Stand gebracht und in die englische Sprache übertragen werden. In der Anwendung agiler Entwicklung Methoden waren die in Betracht kommenden Nearshoring-Teams uns oft weit voraus. Es musste also umgehend ein Trainingsprogramm für die internen Mitarbeiter aufgesetzt werden.

Die aufwändige Transformation der gesamten Entwicklung, dem Herzstück des Unternehmens, musste entsprechend durch ehrgeizige Wachstumsziele auf einem glücklicherweise noch nicht gesättigten Markt gerechtfertigt werden.

Das bedeutete unter anderem die Unterstützung verschiedener nationaler Architekturstandards für den öffentlichen Personenverkehr (ÖPV). Nach Innen mussten Produkt- und Projektgeschäft separiert und professionalisiert werden.

Die schonungslos dargestellte realistische Investitionsprognose als wesentlicher Teil eines langfristigen Geschäftsplans sorgte bei den Gesellschaftern zunächst für Stirnrunzeln, wurde aber schließlich akzeptiert.

Teil dessen war unter anderem eine vorgeschlagene neue Führungsstruktur für den Bereich "Professional Services", die Einstellung eines Produktmanagers und eines Service-Delivery-Managers und schließlich die Übergabe an das neue Management.

Ergebnis

Einerseits trug die neue Transparenz dazu bei, der Geschäftsführung und dem Verwaltungsrat die Augen für den Ernst der Lage und die Höhe der im Laufe der Jahre angehäuften "technischen Schulden" zu öffnen.

Auf der anderen Seite entwickelte das Revitalisierungsprogramm eine starke Überzeugungskraft. Die vorgestellte Vision wurde durch solide numerische Berechnungen gestützt. Der vorgestellt Business Plan wies zwar hohe Investitionen zur Tilgung der über die vergangenen Jahre angehäuften technischen Schulden aus. Insgesamt versprach der Business Plan jedoch einen positiven Cashflow nach rund zwei Jahren.

In der Zwischenzeit zeigten die Ad-hoc-Aktivitäten erste positive Ergebnisse und stärkten das Vertrauen in die Durchführbarkeit dieses Projekts. Mit neuer Hoffnung und den ersten positiven Signalen des Marktes verlieh die Übergabe an das neue Management dem Unternehmen neuen Schwung und wurde allgemein als Neuanfang wahrgenommen.

Dr. Horst Walther

SiG Software Integration GmbH
Große Bleichen 1-3
20354 Hamburg

horst.walther@si-g.com
https//www.si-g.com

+49 171 214 55 02

2024-11-28

Scientist – a doubtful neologism?


Reading the following text left me wondering, if there are more of such examples: words starting in Greek and ending in Latin or the other way round, or even more dramatically mixed.

“They say it is an ugly hybrid with a Latin root and a Greek termination…. Even if the accusation were true, those who swallow ‘voltmeter’ and ‘ionisation’ would scarcely strain at such a very mild inelegance.”

In a letter to the editor of Nature in 1924, an author asked the journal to adopt the word ‘scientist’ instead of regarding it a ‘dubious neologism’, but rather a useful term that recognises the common thread of the scientific method.

After short research with a little help of my chatbot buddy, I quickly found out, that the linguistic mixing of Greek and Latin roots, known as macaronic hybridisation, is quite common in the English language, especially in scientific and technical terms. Many of these hybrids arose naturally as Greek and Latin were the primary sources of vocabulary for the sciences, and their mixing was seen as practical rather than puristic.

Here's a list of some notable examples, categorized by their composition:

Greek Root + Latin Suffix

  1. Television (Greek: "tele-" = distant + Latin: "vision" = sight)
  2. Thermometer (Greek: "thermo-" = heat + Latin: "-meter" = measure)
  3. Astrology (Greek: "astro-" = star + Latin: "-logy" = study)
  4. Biography (Greek: "bio-" = life + Latin: "-graphy" = writing)
  5. Philosophy (Greek: "philo-" = love + Latin: "-sophy" = wisdom)

Latin Root + Greek Suffix

  1. Aquaphobia (Latin: "aqua" = water + Greek: "-phobia" = fear)
  2. Decimetre (Latin: "deci-" = tenth + Greek: "-meter" = measure)
  3. Multiverse (Latin: "multi-" = many + Greek: "-verse" = universe)
  4. Carnivorous (Latin: "carni-" = flesh + Greek: "-vorous" = eating)
  5. Luminiferous (Latin: "lumin-" = light + Greek: "-ferous" = carrying)

Dramatically Mixed Words

These words combine more freely between Greek and Latin elements:

  1. Heliocentric (Greek: "helio-" = sun + Latin: "-centric" = centered)
  2. Electrolysis (Greek: "electro-" = amber (electricity) + Latin: "-lysis" = loosening or dissolving)
  3. Anthropology (Greek: "anthropo-" = human + Latin: "-logy" = study)
  4. Homosexual (Greek: "homo-" = same + Latin: "-sexual" = relating to sex)
  5. Geostationary (Greek: "geo-" = Earth + Latin: "-stationary" = standing still)

Pure Hybrids in Common Use

  1. Automobile (Greek: "auto-" = self + Latin: "mobilis" = movable)
  2. Neonatal (Greek: "neo-" = new + Latin: "natal" = birth-related)
  3. Hydraulic (Greek: "hydro-" = water + Latin: "-aulic" = pipe or channel)
  4. Palaeontology (Greek: "paleo-" = ancient + Latin: "-logy" = study)
  5. Periscope (Greek: "peri-" = around + Latin: "-scope" = to see)

Why This Happens

  • Greek was the dominant language for early philosophy, science, and medicine.

  • Latin was the language of the Roman Empire and became the lingua franca of scholars in Europe.

  • When modern scientific terminology evolved, scholars borrowed elements from both languages, often mixing them to describe new concepts.

Some Fun Factoids

  • This practice of hybridisation sometimes raised eyebrows among purists, as shown in the Nature letter you referenced. However, practicality and the evolution of language often win out over strict adherence to linguistic purity.

  • The term "scientist", as criticized in the example, was coined in the early 19th century by William Whewell, combining the Latin "-ist" suffix with the root "science," itself from the Latin "scientia."

The evolution of language often wins out over strict adherence to linguistic purity. Nevertheless, we should be aware of the words we are using. They may tell their own stories. Words often carry histories within them, quietly telling stories about the evolution of ideas, cultures, and even power dynamics.

Linguistic choices aren't just about communication; they're a window into the past and a reflection of the creativity and pragmatism of human thought. Language, after all, is humanity's oldest shared tool, constantly adapting to new contexts while carrying echoes of the old.

Mixing Greek and Latin roots is like weaving together threads from two great civilizations to create new conceptual fabric. It’s a testament to how interconnected human knowledge has always been. And the way we continue to innovate with language—whether through hybrids like television or playful reinventions—is a reminder that language itself is alive, as dynamic as the cultures it serves.

So, at least in those composite words humanity is living in perfect harmony, like ebony and ivory on the Piano 😊

2024-08-02

Kleine Überraschung für den Interim Manager

 


Die Wahrheit erfährst Du oft erst, wenn, wenn Du bereits mittendrin steckst.

Vor meiner Karriere als Interim-Manager habe ich aus praktischer Erfahrung als Unternehmensberater gelernt, dass es drei ehrliche Gründe geben kann, warum ein Unternehmen einen externen Berater hinzuzieht:

  1. Um Spezial-Know How zu erwerben oder zumindest zu nutzen, das sie intern nicht haben oder nicht bereithalten wollen,

  2. Um fehlende Kapazitäten zu kompensieren, insbesondere um Veränderungsaktivitäten zu ermöglichen, und

  3. Um einen unvoreingenommenen externen Blick auf die interne Situation zu erhalten, möglicherweise kombiniert mit dem Mehrwert der Positionierung im Markt im Vergleich zu anderen.

Und dann gibt es eine Reihe von nicht so ehrlichen, nicht so anständigen Gründen, um externe Expertise zu nutzen: um heimliche verborgene Aktivitäten in internen Machtkämpfen zu befeuern, um die eigene Untätigkeit in Notfällen zu vertuschen, um einen Konkurrenten aus dem Rennen um die Spitze zu werfen ... Es gibt mehr solcher Fälle, als sich ein kranker Geist vorstellen kann.

Um ehrlich zu sein, hatte ich anfangs keine Ahnung davon, musste aber schnell dazulernen.

Als ich dann das Feld des Interim-Managements betrat, stieß ich auf einen ähnlichen Dualismus von Wahrnehmung und Realität, den ich gerne mit Euch teilen möchte.

1 Unangenehme Entdeckungen 

Das Management eines Programms zur Zentralisierung von 25 regionalen Instanzen eines veralteten Kernbankensystems und dessen Ersatz durch ein neues und modernes System war eine gewaltige, aber prestigeträchtige Aufgabe. Gut, dass das Unternehmen dafür einige zusätzliche, qualifizierte Ressourcen unter Vertrag genommen hatte. Es sollte mithin machbar sein, so dachte ich.

Unter der sichtbaren Oberfläche hatte der Eisberg jedoch eine enorme Basis aus unsichtbaren Herausforderungen, denen begegnet werden musste, um den Erfolg zu gewährleisten.

  • Die 25 Instanzen waren in sehr unterschiedlichem Zustand, in verschiedenen Versionen, wurden auf unterschiedliche Weise gemäß sehr unterschiedlichen Prozessen genutzt. Da Kunden in den Regionen unterschiedliche Vorlieben in Bezug auf die genutzten Bankprodukte hatten, war an diesen Stellen oft auch unterschiedliche Funktionalität implementiert worden.

  • Verfügbarkeit und Sicherheit, obwohl nicht gerade berauschend und oft bemängelt, waren aufgrund des verteilten Risikos erträglich – mit der Zentralisierung war aber eine erhebliche Verbesserung erforderlich. Business Continuity Management, Standardarbeitsanweisungen und Cybersicherheit bedurften alle einer deutlichen Professionalisierung.

  • Schließlich erfuhr ich, dass ich nicht der erste war, der diesen Auftrag erhielt. Einige Vorgänger hatten es vor mir versucht – und waren gescheitert. Die Hoffnung auf einen gemeinsamen Erfolg in dem inzwischen erschöpften Team zu nähren, erwies sich als keine leichte Aufgabe. Kurz gesagt, es stellte sich heraus, dass ich eine gute Gelegenheit haben würde, etwas „Spaß“ zu haben.

2 Glänzende Zahlen – verborgene Schulden

Nach einigen Jahren hatte ich eine zweite Chance zu glänzen – oder in die Falle zu tappen ...

Ein Manager einer Fachabteilung mit rund 60 Mitarbeitern bei einem Softwareanbieter für den öffentlichen Personentransport hatte plötzlich das „Handtuch geworfen“ und gekündigt. Sehr bald sollte ein neues, vielversprechendes Produkt der nächsten Generation auf dem ungeduldig wartenden Markt eingeführt werden. Alle finanziellen Zahlen, die der Zentrale gemeldet wurden, sahen gut bis hervorragend aus, vielleicht ein wenig zu gut.

Nur noch ein paar letzte Tests mussten durchgeführt werden, bevor der neue Stolz des Unternehmens in die freie Wildbahn entlassen werden konnte.

Diesmal bestand ich allerdings auf einer 6-wöchigen Analyse vor Übernahme meiner Aufgabe. Außerdem äußerte ich den Wunsch, zwei weitere Kollegen hinzuziehen zu können, die zwar erfahrene „alte Hasen“, aber gleichzeitig mit den neuesten Methoden vertraut waren – eine seltene Kombination. Ein unbestimmtes Bauchgefühl am Anfang sagte mir nämlich, dass ich alleine nicht in der Lage sein würde, die Herausforderungen all der verborgenen Schichten zu bewältigen, sollte es da mehr geben als auf den ersten Blick erkennbar war.

Und wie sich herausstellte, lauerten da tatsächlich einige Monster im Untergrund.

  • Die „paar letzten Tests“ waren in Bezug auf Teamgröße und Fähigkeiten dramatisch unterbesetzt. Diese kritische Projektphase war, weil die Zeit am Ende knapp wurde, in einen lächerlich engen Zeitplan gepresst worden,

  • Niemand hatte eine Ahnung, wie viele Fehler zu erwarten waren oder wie man sie schätzen sollte, die Anwendung von Fehlermodellen war unbekannt.

  • Da die Entwicklung traditionell weit hinter dem Zeitplan lag, wurden notwendige Refaktorisierungsschritte verschoben oder ganz übersprungen, was zu einer nun fehlerhaften Architektur führte. Infolgedessen hatte sich im Laufe der Jahre eine riesige Menge technischer Schulden angesammelt.

  • Als ob das nicht genug wäre, hatten Anschuldigungen und gegenseitige Vorwürfe innerhalb des Teams zu gestörter Kommunikation und in einigen Bereichen zu einer toxischen Kultur der Zusammenarbeit geführt.

  • Es ist fast überflüssig zu erwähnen, dass in der Entwicklung, Wartung und Projektmanagement veraltete Methoden verwendet wurden,

  • Unsere Kunden hatten ihre sensiblen Antennen bereits auf uns ausgerichtet. Bei Vor-Ort-Besuchen ließen sie uns an ihrem deutlichen Unbehagen teilhaben.

Die Liste könnte weitergehen, das aber Top-Management gab sich ahnungslos: Fehler passieren nun 'mal, keine Software ist frei davon. Warum können die Kunden denn niemals zufrieden sein?

3 Der Betrieb frisst Deine ganze Zeit

Bei meinem dritten Interim-Einsatz wurde ich beauftragt, Marktforschung, Bewertung, Auswahl, Einkauf und Einführung bis zum Go-Live einer neuen wichtigen Infrastruktursoftware durchzuführen. Ich war jetzt erfahrener, gut ausgerüstet mit meinem Sieben-Schritte-Auswahlverfahren und in guter Stimmung.

Und doch, da mein Vorgänger in dieser Rolle das Unternehmen plötzlich in einer Art Panikmodus verlassen hatte, fand ich dort eine große Verwirrung unter den Himmeln vor. Natürlich musste als kleine Nebenaufgabe, kaum erwähnenswert, das operative Geschäft überwacht werden.

Es stellte sich heraus, dass das operative Tagesgeschäft, durch eine miserable Datenqualität, kombiniert mit nicht vorhandenen Prozessdefinitionen und unterirdischen Fähigkeiten des unterbesetzten Teams, bis zu 80% meiner verfügbaren Zeit beanspruchte. Die hastige Implementierung einiger provisorischer Teilautomatisierungen durch Skripte und Bürosoftware konsumierte weitere 15%, was nur 5% für die Aufgabe ließ, für die ich engagiert worden war.

Mittlerweile hatte ich jedoch gelernt, dass ein Interim-Manager intern ist, das bedeutet, er kann von innen heraus agieren und Entscheidungen über Budget, Ziele und Ressourcenzuweisung im Allgemeinen beeinflussen. Am Ende rettete es mich, diese Karte zu spielen. Es ermöglichte mir, einen Berater zu engagieren, der mich bei den eher generischen und daher auslagerbaren Aufgaben unterstützte.

4 Diese Erfahrungen machten mich nachdenklich. 

Was ist da passiert? Wurde ich absichtlich über die wahre Natur des Jobs im Unklaren gelassen? Wollten meine Kunden mich böswillig in eine Falle locken? Oder glaubten sie selbst wirklich und aufrichtig, was sie mir über die aktuelle Situation erzählten? Sahen sie nur die Spitze des Eisbergs und erkannten die darunter lauernden Bedrohungen nicht? Oder zogen sie es vor, nicht so genau hinzuschauen? Schließlich ist bisher immer alles gut gegangen, wie die Zahlen „bewiesen“.

Wenn es um Interim-Management geht, lautet das vorherrschende Narrativ „eine Vakanz überbrücken“. Es wird allgemein angenommen, dass ein Manager einer wichtigen Unternehmensfunktion aus irgendeinem Grund plötzlich ausfällt. Es kann einige Zeit dauern, bis ein neuer Manager, der richtige, ernannt wird und sich in die Rolle eingearbeitet hat. In der Zwischenzeit muss die Lücke gefüllt werden. Dieser kapazitätsbedingte Bedarf wird von denen als Hauptgrund angesehen, die weniger mit diesen Umständen zu tun haben – und in einigen Fällen entspricht dieses allgemeine Verständnis sogar der Realität.

Das Expertise-Argument gilt wie in der Beratung so auch hier, jedoch in Verbindung mit einer Umsetzung. Und schließlich kommt es manchmal sogar vor, dass de Wunsch, die Aktivitäten diesmal anders zu gestalten, z.B. durch die Einführung von Lean- oder Agile-Managementpraktiken, keine andere Wahl lässt, als die richtige Person für diese schwierige Aufgabe von außen zu engagieren, um eine turbulente Zeit zu bewältigen – bis sich der Staub gelegt haben würde.

Meistens jedoch wird schnell klar, dass es da noch mehr zu tun gibt.

Die ignorierten Schulden, die verborgenen Schichten, die ebenfalls bearbeitet werden müssen, existieren tatsächlich. Dass niemand davon wüsste, ist eher seltener der Fall. In den meisten Fällen haben die Kollegen eine recht gute Vorstellung von dem aufgestauten Handlungsbedarf sowie den Fähigkeiten und Möglichkeiten ihrer eigenen Organisation. Sie unterschätzen möglicherweise nur die Größe der Altlasten und ihre möglichen Auswirkungen.

Aber der Prophet gilt bekanntlich nichts in seiner eigenen Organisation. Jeder Überbringer schlechter Nachrichten wird beschuldigt, insgeheim eigennützige Motive zu verfolgen. Sie stehen für unangenehme Wahrheiten, die normalerweise zu deutlich mehr Aufwand, höheren Kosten und Terminverzügen führen würden. Das Management würde am liebsten gar keine Nachrichten hören, es sei denn, es sind gute Nachrichten. So schleicht sich eine Art „Hofberichterstattung“ ein: Die Zahlen, die nach oben gemeldet werden, sehen gut aus. Aber darunter schwelen die Probleme weiter – bis sie irgendwann nicht mehr verborgen werden können.

Die Schlussfolgerung lautet: Niemand will Dich in eine Falle locken oder lügt Dich absichtlich an. Vielmehr führen häufig Selbsttäuschung, bequeme Illusionen und gestörte Kommunikation oder erfolgreich geübte Ignoranz letztlich zu unangenehmen Entdeckungen.

Also sei besser auf eine Überraschung vorbereitet, wenn Du einmal etwas tiefer bohrst.


2024-07-31

The Interim Managers’ surprise


Often you aren’t told the truth until you are in 

Prior to my career as an interim manager, while working as a management consultant, I learned by practical experience that there can be three honest reasons for a company to bring in an external consultant: 

  • To acquire or at least utilise specialist knowledge that they do not have or do not want to maintain internally,

  • to supplement insufficient capacity, in particular to enable change activities and

  • to obtain an unbiased external view of the internal situation, possibly combined with the added value of positioning in the market compared to others

And then there are a number of not-so-honest, not-so-decent reasons to use external expertise to fuel clandestine underground activities in internal turf wars, to cover up one's own inaction in emergencies, to throw a competitor out of the race for the top ... There are more such cases that even a sick mind can imagine.

To be honest, I had no idea at first, but I had to learn quickly.

Then, when I entered the arena of interim management, I came across a similar dualism of perception and reality that I would like to share with you.

1 Unpleasant discoveries

Managing the programme to centralise 25 regional instances of an outdated core banking system and replace it with a new and modern system was a daunting but prestigious task. Good thing they hired some additional, qualified resources. It should be doable, I thought. 

Beneath the visible surface, however, the iceberg had an enormous base of invisible challenges that were waiting to be solved as a prerequisite for success.

  • The 25 instances were in a widely different shape, of various versions, were used in a variety of different ways according to very distinct processes. As customers in den regions had diverse preference regarding the consumed banking products, different functionality was prevalent there too.

  • Availability and security, while not great and often bemoaned, were tolerable due to distributed risk - but a significant boost was required with centralisation. Business continuity management, standard operating procedures, cyber security all required a substantial improvement.

  • My assignment, I learnt, was not the first. A few predecessors had tried before me - and failed. Nurturing the hope of joint success in the now exhausted team turned out to be no easy task.

In short, it turned out that there would be a decent chance to have some fun.

2 Brilliant numbers – hidden debts

After a few years had passed, I had a second chance to shine - or fall into the trap ...

A manager of a professional services department with around 60 employees at a software provider for public transport suddenly threw in the towel and resigned. Very soon, a new, promising next-generation product was due to be launched on an impatiently waiting market. All the financial figures reported to the head office looked good to excellent, perhaps a little too good.

Only a few final tests needed to be carried out before the company's new pride and joy could be released into the wild.

This time I insisted on a 6 weeks analysis. Also, I demanded to add two more colleges, who were experienced seniors but have kept up with newest methodologies at the same time – a rare combination. A gut feeling at the beginning told me that, if there is more to it than meets the eye, I alone will not be able to cope with the challenges of all those hidden layers.

And, as it turned out, there indeed was more to it.

  • Those “few final tests” were dramatically understaffed regarding team size and skills. This critical phase was squeezed into a ridiculously tight schedule,

  • No one had any ideas about how many flaws were to expect nor how to estimate them, the application of error models was unknown,

  • As development was usually behind schedule, necessary refactoring steps were postponed or skipped altogether, resulting in a now flawed architecture. As a result, a huge amount of technical debt had accumulated over the years.

  • As if this were not enough, recriminations and mutual accusations within the team had led to distorted communication and, in some areas, a toxic culture of cooperation, 

  • Almost superfluous to mention that outdated methods were used in development, maintenance and project management,

  • Customers had also adjusted their sensitive antennae. They now felt increasingly uncomfortable, as on-site visits revealed.

The list could go on, but the top management had no idea: mistakes happen, no software is free of ‘bugs’. Why can customers never be satisfied?

3 Operations eats up your time

In my 3rd interim assignment, I was tasked with market research, evaluation, selection, purchasing and introduction until go-live of a major new infrastructure software. I was more experienced now, was well-equipped with my seven-steps procedure at hand and in a good mood.

And yet, as my predecessor in that role had left the company all in a sudden in a kind of panic mode, I found there a great confusion under the heavens. Of course, as a minor side-task, hardly worth mentioning, operational business had to be supervised meanwhile.

I turned out that a lousy data quality combined with non-existent process definitions and subterranean skills of the understaffed team the BAU (Business as usual) or business operations took up to 80% of my available time. Hasty implementation of some makeshift semi-automation through scripting and office software accounted for another 15%, leaving a mere 5% for the obligation I was contracted for.

Meanwhile however I had learned that an interim manager is internal, means he may act from inside, influencing decisions about budget, goals and resource allocation in general. In the end playing this card saved me by allowing me to contract a consultant to support me in the more generic and hence outsourceable tasks.

4 Those experiences left me wondering.

What had happened there? Was I deliberately lied to about the true nature of the job? Did my clients intend to lure you into a trap? Or did they themselves truly and sincerely believe what they were telling me about the current situation? Did they only see the tip of the iceberg and didn't even recognise the threats lurking beneath the surface? Or did they prefer not to look so closely? After all, everything has always gone well so far, as the figures ‘prove’.

When it comes to interim management, the prevailing narrative is ‘bridging a vacancy’. It is generally assumed that a manager of an important company function suddenly drops out for some reason. It may take some time for a new manager, the right one, to be appointed and for him/her to quickly familiarise with the new role. Meanwhile the gap needs to be filled. This capacity-related need is seen as the main reason by those who have less to do with these circumstances - and in some rare cases this general understanding even corresponds to reality.

The expertise argument like in the consulting business also applies here, but in conjunction with the expectation of execution. And finally, sometimes it even happens that the willingness to do the work differently this time, e.g. changing management practices to Lean or Agile, leaves no choice but to hire the right person for this difficult task to lead through a turbulent time - until the dust settles.  

More often than not, however, it quickly becomes apparent that there is more to it. 

The ignored debts, the hidden layers, which also need to be worked on, do indeed exist. Rarely is it the case that nobody has seen them. In most cases, colleagues have a good idea of the capabilities and possibilities of their own organisation. They may just underestimate the size and impact.

But the prophets are not well received in their own organisation. Every bearer of bad news is accused of being secretly self-serving. They deliver uncomfortable truths anyway, which would usually lead to significantly more effort, higher costs and later deadlines. Management would prefer not to hear any news at all, unless it is good news. So, a kind of ‘court reporting’ creeps in: The figures that are reported upwards look good. But underneath, the problems continue to smoulder - until at some point they can no longer be hidden.

The conclusion is: Nobody wants to lure you into a trap or is deliberately lying to you. Rather, self-deception, cosy illusions and distorted or even muted communication or traditional ignorance often lead to an unpleasant surprise. 

So you better be prepared for a surprise once you dig a little deeper.

2024-07-23

7 questions about the job of an interim manager

 


A couple of years ago, my son came back from school with the homework assignment to describe his father's job in a short interview of about 7 questions. My challenge was to keep it short, emphasise the essentials and make it understandable for my son's classmates. My son got a good grade for it. And even today, after all these years, I think this concise but timeless document has retained its power. What do you think?

1 What is your profession?

My profession is that of an interim manager, that is a manager for a limited period of time, hence ‘interim’. An interim manager actually does what a ‘normal’, i.e. salaried, manager does. Frequently however he finds himself in a special situation. The interim manager usually is called in when a salaried manager suddenly is no longer available. Or it may be that there are tasks to be completed for which it is better to employ someone ‘from outside’.

2 Why did you choose this career

The tasks that an interim manager has to perform rarely resembles the usual operational routine. Due to the special situation in which he is deployed, his tasks are nearly always new and exciting. Creating something new in a constantly changing company has a special appeal for me. It never gets boring. And that's why I chose this job.  By the way, it's not badly paid either.

3 What training did you have to complete and how long did it take?

There is no proper training programme for interim managers. This job profile is relatively new. The requirements profile to be fulfilled is not (yet) formally defined. Nevertheless, an interim manager must have a range of skills. It is good if they were once managers in a senior position themselves. But the skills, knowledge and experience of a management consultant are also very helpful here. From the list above, it has certainly become clear that an interim manager should have gained several years of experience in a responsible position after completing his studies. This can easily add up to 5 to 10 years of professional experience before you take on such a role.

4 What activities do you carry out in your job?

On the one hand, I continue the operational business that I took over from my predecessor.  However, as this is generally not enough, I set up one or more change projects. These should revitalise the company or make it fit for certain important projects in the first place.  To do this, I need to have a good understanding of the business, i.e. the markets, customers, suppliers and service processes. As this is about change management, I also need to take the people involved ‘on the journey’.  After all, the plans will only succeed if everyone is on board.

5 What advantages and disadvantages do you experience in your job?

The advantages of this profession also entail its disadvantages. And what I see as an advantage, others may see as a disadvantage. I see the advantages: Always new tasks in new companies, but also in new locations and with new people. The tension that arises when it's not entirely clear at the beginning whether the big change will succeed. And in the end, the satisfaction of having succeeded, perhaps having saved an entire company.

That actually already lists the disadvantages: The uncertainty of the new situation, long and very stressful working days, travelling times, the pressure of expectations that weighs on me, sometimes even outright rejection. And there's not always anything that can be salvaged. Those are rather sad cases then.

6 Do you have to do regular training or is that not necessary in your job? 

Yes, of course I do. Maybe that's nothing special nowadays. Don't we have to keep on learning in every profession? However, an interim manager is often called in when a company has ’missed the train’ to an essential development. He himself must therefore always be up to date, both professionally and in terms of working and management methodology. There is no set training programme for this. A lot of personal initiative is hence required.

4.7 Do you know of any professions that are similar to yours? 

The job of a manager in a volatile environment, i.e. in markets that change quickly, probably faces similar challenges. Project managers of major projects or explicit change management projects, so-called change managers, can also grow into such a role.  And finally, management consultants who are not afraid to implement their own recommendations within the company may have a similar job profile.

7 Fragen zum Beruf eines Interim Managers

Vor einigen Jahren kam mein Sohn mit der Hausaufgabe aus der Schule zurück, den Beruf seines Vaters in Form eines kurzen Interviews von etwa 7 Fragen zu beschreiben. Meine Herausforderung bestand darin, mich kurz zu fassen, das Wesentliche hervorzuheben und für die Mitschüler meines Sohns verständlich zu formulieren. Mein Sohn bekam dafür eine gute Note. Und noch heute, so meine ich, nach all den Jahren hat dieses knappe aber zeitlose Dokument seine Aussagekraft behalten. Was meint Ihr?

1 Was ist Dein Beruf?

Mein Beruf ist der eines Interim Managers, also eines Mangers auf Zeit, daher „Interim“. Ein Interim Manager macht eigentlich das, was ein „normaler“, also angestellter, Manager auch macht. Eigentlich – denn häufig befindet es sich doch in einer Sondersituation. Die entsteht dadurch, dass ein angestellter Manager plötzlich nicht mehr zur Verfügung steht. Oder es kann sein, dass Aufgaben zu erledigen sind, für die man lieber jemand „von draußen“ nimmt.

2 Warum hast Du diesen Beruf gewählt

Die Aufgaben, die ein Interim Manager zu erledigen hat, entstammen selten der üblichen operativen Routine. Aufgrund der Sondersituation, in der er eingesetzt wird, sind auch seine Aufgaben immer wieder neu und spannend. In immer wieder neuen Unternehmen, Neues zu schaffen, das hat für mich seinen besonderen Reiz. Das wird nie langweilig. Und deshalb habe ich diesen Beruf gewählt.  Übrigens, schlecht bezahlt wird er auch nicht.

3 Welche Ausbildung musstest Du absolvieren, wie lange dauerte die Ausbildung?

Eine regelrechte Ausbildung zum Interim Manager gibt es nicht. Dieses Berufsbild ist vergleichsweise neu. Das zu erfüllende Anforderungsprofil ist (noch) nicht formal definiert. Dennoch muss ein Interim Manager eine Reihe von Fähigkeiten mitbringen.  Gut ist es, wenn er selber einmal ein Manager in einer leitenden Position war. Aber auch die Fähigkeiten, Kenntnisse und Erfahrungen eines Unternehmensberaters sind hier sehr hilfreich. Aus der Aufzählung ist sicher klar geworden, dass ein Interim Manager nach seinem Studium einige Jahre Erfahrung in verantwortlicher Position gesammelt haben sollte. Da kommen dann leicht 5 bis 10 Jahre Berufserfahrung zusammen, bevor man eine solche Aufgabe übernimmt.

4 Welche Tätigkeiten übst Du in Deinem Beruf aus?

Zum einen führe ich das operative Geschäft weiter, das ich von meinem Vorgänger übernommen habe.  Da es damit aber in aller Regel nicht getan ist, setze ich eines oder mehrere Veränderungsprojekte auf. Diese sollten dazu führen, das Unternehmen wieder zu revitalisieren oder überhaupt erst fit zu machen für bestimmte wichtige Vorhaben.  Dazu muss ich ein gutes Verständnis vom Geschäft haben, also von den Märkten, den Kunden, Lieferanten und den Leistungsprozessen. Da es um Change-Management geht, muss ich aber auch die beteiligten Menschen mit „auf die Reise“ nehmen.  Denn nur, wenn auch alle mitmachen, werden die Vorhaben gelingen.

5 Welche Vor- und Nachteile erlebst Du in Deinem Beruf?

Die Vorteile dieses Berufes bedingen auch gleichzeitig seine Nachteile. Und das, was ich als Vorteil sehe, mögen Andere vielleicht eher als Nachteil empfinden. Ich sehe als Vorteile: Immer wieder neue Aufgaben in neuen Unternehmen, aber auch an neuen Standorten und mit neuen Menschen. Die Spannung, die entsteht, wenn zu Beginn noch nicht ganz klar ist, ob die große Veränderung auch gelingen wird. Und hinterher die Befriedigung, es geschafft zu haben, vielleicht ein ganzes Unternehmen gerettet zu haben.

Damit sind eigentlich auch schon die Nachteile aufgezählt: Die Ungewissheit der neuen Situation, lange und sehr anstrengende Arbeitstage, Reisezeiten, der Erwartungsdruck, der auf mir lastet, manchmal auch offene Ablehnung. Und nicht immer ist noch etwas zu retten. Das ist dann eher traurig.

6 Musst Du Dich regelmäßig fortbilden oder ist das in Deinem Beruf nicht notwendig? 

Doch, das muss ich natürlich. Vielleicht ist das heute nichts Besonderes mehr. Müssen wir uns nicht in jedem Beruf fortwährend weiterbilden? Ein Interim Manager aber wird häufig gerufen, wenn ein Unternehmen eine Entwicklung „verschlafen“ hat. Er selber muss also sowohl fachlich, wie von den Arbeits- und Managementmethoden her immer auf der Höhe der Zeit sein. Dafür gibt es keinen festgelegten Ausbildungsgang. Da ist viel Eigeninitiative gefragt.

7 Kennst Du Berufe die Deinem ähnlich sind? 

Der Beruf eines Managers in einem volatilen Umfeld, also in Märkten, die sich schnell ändern, hat sich vermutlich ähnlichen Herausforderungen zu stellen. Projektleiter von Großprojekten oder expliziten Change-Management Projekten, sogenannte Change Manager, können auch in eine solche Rolle hineinwachsen.  Und schließlich können Unternehmensberater, die sich nicht scheuen, Ihre eigenen Empfehlungen im Unternehmen auch umzusetzen, ein durchaus ähnliches Berufsbild aufweisen.


2024-06-15

The third evolution

Collective Artificial Intelligence (CAI)

Well, CAI is not (yet) an established Acronym, or at least not in the sense as an abbreviation of this contributions’ sub-title.

Underlying the claim that comes along with that title is a lengthy thought which crossed my mind while listening to a panel discussion on “Intelligence in the Age of LLMs: Synthesizing with AI Toward Meta-Knowing” on Wednesday, June 05 at this years’ European Identity Conference (EIC 2024). 

The illustrious panel was comprised of ...

  • Dr. Scott David, LL.M., Executive Director - Information Risk and Synthetic Intelligence Research Initiative, University of Washington - APL,

  • Daniel Friedman, Co-Founder and President Active Inference Institute,

  • Trent McConaghy, Founder Ocean Protocol and 

  • Dr. Mihaela Ulieru, Founder and President IMPACT Institute for the Digital Economy

Their talk promised to open a treasure chest of insights into the evolution of intelligence. After a while, my thoughts took on a life of their own and following a storyline that went like this:

1 Collective Human Intelligence - The second evolution

The success of the human race stems not only from the various contributions of intelligent individuals, but to a possibly greater extent to the intelligent interaction of these individuals with each other. Humans are highly social creatures, and much of our progress and survival has depended on our ability to co-operate, communicate, and share knowledge. Collective interaction has given rise to skills that far surpass those of a single individual. 

These artefacts, which complexity theory refers to as emergent effects, ultimately triggered a second, cultural evolution based on these emergent properties of human social interaction. As a result, humanity ultimately became human. This position is supported by a wealth of literature from fields such as evolutionary biology, anthropology, cognitive science and complexity theory.

Complexity theory in particular studies how interactions among components of a system lead to complex behaviours and properties that are not evident from the properties of the individual components. 

Emergent effects in this context are defined as phenomena that arise from these interactions. They include:

  1. Nonlinearity - Small changes in initial conditions or interactions can lead to disproportionately large effects.

  2. Self-Organization - Systems can spontaneously organize into patterns or structures without external direction.

  3. Adaptation - Systems can adapt to changes in their environment through feedback mechanisms.

  4. Decentralization - Emergent behaviours typically arise from local interactions among components rather than being directed by a central authority.

In the context of human societies, emergent effects manifest as cultural norms, institutions, languages, and technologies that evolve from the collective behaviours and interactions of individuals.

2 Collective Artificial Intelligence - The third evolution

Most artificial intelligence systems, on the other hand, are currently designed and implemented as individual, isolated models, unaware of the existence of others of their kind. They do not inherently communicate with each other nor do they exchange knowledge.

Rather, the trend is to develop larger, more comprehensive models based on huge amounts of data and aiming for superhuman performance in certain tasks in order to eventually achieve a "god-like" status. The concept of a god (not a pantheon) is ultimately that of a superior individual in no need of  "a little help from his friend". Since there are clearly no equal peers, it is unlikely that this evolutionary path favours more intense communication.

However, if we want to apply the concept of collective behaviour to instances of artificial intelligence, at whatever stage of development, do we expect to observe emergent effects there as well, possibly leading to capabilities and behaviours that surpass those of individual AI systems? 

As cultural evolution builds on biological evolution, could a new form of evolution emerge from the interaction of AI systems? This "third evolution" could then be characterised by the development of a collective artificial intelligence that makes use of emergent properties from the interaction of AI systems with AI systems. 

Will we eventually see the development of a superintelligent AI in the form of a network or collective of interconnected systems, rather than a single, isolated superintelligent AI?  This collective intelligence could potentially have capabilities that surpass any single AI system. 

How would this AI collective interact with the incumbent collective, us humans? The interaction between an AI collective and human society could lead to a symbiotic relationship involving co-operation, competition or even co-evolution, where both benefit from each other's strengths. However, it also raises ethical and practical concerns about control, transparency and the alignment of AI goals with human values.

3 Speculation

There is much room for speculation indeed. 

If the course of thought up to this point has already been guided by quite esoteric considerations, then the path that may lie ahead of us is even more shrouded in thick fog.

Would such a scenario even be possible after all? Well, emergent effects can occur even from the interaction of individuals on a rather low level. Instances of individual intelligence on the other hand have currently reached a by far higher degree of autonomy in their decisions. Even higher levels are expected to be achieved. While these levels don’t represent a necessary precondition for the occurrence of emergent effects, to kick off an evolution of its own kind however, they must at least be capable of processing feedback from those effects in order to incentivise successful group behaviour and discourage less promising set-ups.

Most probably this scenario can be expected to effectively work even below the level of Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) of the participating individuals. The speed of this 3rd evolution will certainly accelerate tremendously once the AGI level is reached or even surpassed by the majority of the members of the collective. 

While there is obviously a certain probability that such a scenario might come to life one day, will it be desirable after all? Will humanity benefit from it or should we rather be scared by such possible outcome? In a survey earlier this year, just over half of the 2,778 researchers polled said that there's a five percent chance that humans will be driven to extinction, among other "extremely bad outcomes." At the same time, 68.3 percent of respondents said that "good outcomes from superhuman AI" are more likely than bad ones, showing there's little consensus on the topic among experts. 

Most probably collective AI was not in scope of those experts’ considerations. Nevertheless, to cope with the remaining risks experts and regulators frequently demand the human to stay somewhere in the loop having the last say. Given the history of mankind, however, it remains doubtful, to say the least, that we would be better off in such a case. Looking back, we cannot help but realize that the worst atrocities have been committed to us by our fellow human being. Over the course of human history, the weapons we have at hand to inflict harm to each other have evolved towards impressing levels – our moral standards and the ways we treat each other however have not.

3.1 How did human morality evolve?

While we may be the known evil for ourselves, the behaviour of autonomously acting AI instances, whether as a swarm or not, is completely unknown and still pure fiction. To approach a prediction, we could again take ourselves as a blueprint. For most of human history, the majority of us have been desperately preoccupied with the needs at the base of Maslow's pyramid. The struggle for survival dominated our days. To ensure survival, we had to band together in smaller or larger communities that competed fiercely for the scarce resources of food and shelter. But even within the communities, we competed with our fellow human beings for the same resources. We had to act as members of a community and at the same time as autonomous individuals. This dualism never left us. This is how we have been socialised over the millennia.

On closer inspection, we find ample evidence and scientific theories to suggest that human morality has indeed evolved as a survival mechanism driven by the need to navigate a hostile environment while balancing individual autonomy and collective co-operation. Here are some key points and theories that echo these ideas:

3.2 Key Theories and Evidence

Evolutionary Psychology and Morality:

  • Theory: Evolutionary psychology posits that many human behaviours, including moral behaviours, have evolved to solve recurrent problems faced by our ancestors. These behaviours increase the chances of survival and reproduction.

  • Evidence: Studies show that moral emotions like empathy, guilt, and shame are universal across cultures, suggesting a common evolutionary origin. Research by Frans de Waal on primates indicates that behaviours such as empathy, fairness, and reciprocity are not uniquely human but shared with other social animals.

Social Contract Theory:

  • Theory: The social contract theory, proposed by philosophers like Thomas Hobbes, John Locke, and Jean-Jacques Rousseau, suggests that individuals agree to form societies and accept certain moral rules to ensure mutual protection and benefits.

  • Evidence: Archaeological and anthropological studies show early human societies had norms and rules that promoted cooperation and social order, which were essential for survival in harsh environments.

Kin Selection and Inclusive Fitness:

  • Theory: Proposed by William Hamilton, kin selection theory suggests that behaviours that help genetic relatives are favoured by natural selection because they increase the likelihood of shared genes being passed on.

  • Evidence: Altruistic behaviours are often observed among close relatives, supporting the idea that helping family members enhances the survival of shared genes. Studies on hunter-gatherer societies show that people are more likely to share resources and cooperate with kin.

Reciprocal Altruism:

  • Theory: Introduced by Robert Trivers, reciprocal altruism suggests that individuals help others with the expectation that the favour will be returned in the future, promoting long-term cooperation.

  • Evidence: Experiments and observations show that humans are more likely to help those who have helped them in the past, indicating that reciprocity is a fundamental aspect of human social behaviour.

Group Selection:

  • Theory: Group selection theory, proposed by David Sloan Wilson and E.O. Wilson, argues that natural selection operates not only at the individual level but also at the group level. Groups with cooperative and altruistic members are more likely to survive and reproduce.

  • Evidence: Anthropological evidence shows that human groups with strong social cohesion and cooperative norms were more successful in surviving environmental challenges and conflicts with other groups.

Cultural Evolution and Social Learning:

  • Theory: Cultural evolution theory suggests that moral values and norms are transmitted through social learning and cultural practices, evolving over time to enhance group cohesion and cooperation.

  • Evidence: Research shows that cultural norms and moral values can change rapidly in response to environmental and social pressures, indicating that morality is influenced by both genetic and cultural factors. The work of Joseph Henrich and others on cultural evolution highlights how cultural practices can shape moral behaviours.

3.3 Socialization and Moral Development

Social Learning Theory:

  • Theory: Proposed by Albert Bandura, social learning theory posits that individuals learn moral behaviours by observing and imitating others, especially role models and authority figures.

  • Evidence: Studies show that children develop moral values through interactions with parents, peers, and society, learning what behaviours are acceptable and rewarded.

Moral Development Stages:

  • Theory: Lawrence Kohlberg's stages of moral development describe how individuals progress through different levels of moral reasoning, from obedience to authority to principled reasoning based on universal ethical principles.

  • Evidence: Longitudinal studies support the idea that moral reasoning develops through stages influenced by cognitive development and social experiences.

3.4 Takeaways

Human morality appears to be the result of a complex interplay between evolutionary pressures, socialization, and cultural influences. The need to survive in a hostile environment, both as individuals and as members of a collective, has shaped our moral values and behaviours. Theories such as evolutionary psychology, social contract theory, kin selection, reciprocal altruism, group selection, and cultural evolution provide robust frameworks for understanding the development and function of human morality. Socialization processes further refine these moral values, making them adaptable to the specific cultural and social contexts in which individuals live.

For those inclined to explore these ideas a little further, the work of evolutionary biologists such as Richard Dawkins, anthropologists such as Christopher Boehm and psychologists such as Jonathan Haidt offer extensive insights into the evolution of human morality.

These considerations imply that if AI instances are socialised in a similar way to humans, the result could resemble human behaviour. However, these various theories, each attempting to explain certain observations, are still a long way from making predictions. Before we release swarms of autonomously acting AI individuals (and if they are AGI instances, they could have consciousness and should be recognised as persons), we should definitely run some more rigorous simulations of possible scenarios and carefully examine the moral standards that emerge. Only then can we decide whether a collective artificial intelligence (CAI) could become our terminator or our saviour. 

This should be incentive enough to invest a little time and effort to find answers to these existential questions before the third evolution finally takes off.

4 Evidence in Literature

4.1 Collective Intelligence:

  • Robin Dunbar: Dunbar's work on the social brain hypothesis suggests that the evolution of human intelligence is largely due to the demands of living in complex social groups. His research indicates that larger social groups require more sophisticated social cognition and communication skills.

  • Pinker: In "The Better Angels of Our Nature," Pinker discusses how human cooperation and collective efforts have led to the reduction of violence and the advancement of societies.

4.2 Emergent Effects and Complexity Theory:

  • Murray Gell-Mann: In "The Quark and the Jaguar," Gell-Mann discusses complexity and emergent phenomena in nature, including how simple rules can lead to complex behaviours.

  • Melanie Mitchell: Her book "Complexity: A Guided Tour" explores how complex behaviours and properties emerge from simple interactions in systems ranging from biological organisms to human societies.

4.3 Cultural Evolution:

  • Richard Dawkins: Dawkins introduced the concept of memes in "The Selfish Gene," which describes how cultural information spreads and evolves similarly to genes.

  • Peter J. Richerson and Robert Boyd: Their book "Not By Genes Alone" discusses how culture has played a critical role in human evolution, supporting the idea that cultural evolution is a form of emergent property arising from human social interaction.

5 Prominent Research

5.1 Complex Systems and Emergence:

  1. Elinor Ostrom: Ostrom's research on collective action and the management of common resources demonstrates how groups of individuals can self-organize to create systems that outperform individual efforts.

  2. Francis Heylighen: Heylighen has written extensively on the principles of self-organization and the evolution of complex systems, including the role of collective intelligence in societal development.

  3. Herbert A. Simon: Simon's work on bounded rationality and his studies on the architecture of complexity are foundational in understanding emergent phenomena in human behaviour and organizational systems.

  4. John H. Holland's work on complex adaptive systems offers insights into how systems composed of multiple interacting agents can exhibit emergent behaviour.

  5. Murray Gell-Mann and Melanie Mitchell have written extensively on complexity and emergent phenomena, which can provide a theoretical foundation for understanding emergent effects in AI collectives.

5.2 Collective Intelligence in AI:

  1. Pierre Lévy introduced the concept of collective intelligence, which could be applied to AI. His book "Collective Intelligence: Mankind's Emerging World in Cyberspace" explores how collective intelligence emerges from networked interactions.

  2. Howard Bloom's "Global Brain: The Evolution of Mass Mind from the Big Bang to the 21st Century" discusses the idea of a global brain, which can be extended to consider AI systems as part of this global intelligence network.

5.3 Swarm Intelligence:

  1. Eric Bonabeau and colleagues' work on swarm intelligence, such as in "Swarm Intelligence: From Natural to Artificial Systems," explores how decentralized, self-organizing systems can solve complex problems collectively.

    The principles of swarm intelligence could be applied to develop AI systems that work together to achieve goals beyond the capability of individual AIs.

5.4 Multi-Agent Systems:

  1. Research on multi-agent systems (MAS) investigates how multiple AI agents can interact, cooperate, and compete. This field provides a practical framework for building and studying AI collectives.

    Michael Wooldridge
    's "An Introduction to MultiAgent Systems" is a comprehensive resource on this topic.

5.5 AI and Human Societies:

  1. Nick Bostrom's "Superintelligence: Paths, Dangers, Strategies" considers various scenarios for the development of superintelligent AI, including collective AI systems.

  2. Yoshua Bengio and other AI researchers have discussed the potential for AI to enhance human collective intelligence rather than replace it.